06 June 2005Politics
A Real Town Hall Meeting

Pete Stark : Town Hall Meeting
A few weeks back I become curious about who represented me and I went to the House website where you can type your zip code into a box and find out who your congressperson is. Since I only moved to Alameda after the election, I had no idea. I found out that it was Pete Stark, I went to his webpage and found out that he was holding a town hall meeting in San Leandro, about 10 miles south of where I live. I decided I wanted to go and check it out, more out of curiosity that anything.

I hadn't gone to see a politician speak in over a decade. The last time, in what turned out to be a complete waste, was way back in the 92 election when I went with some friends to Orange County to hear Ross Perot.

There were about 100 to 150 people in the small auditorium at the San Leandro library. Most were from the blue hair set. There were precious people my age or younger. Stark, who's a Democrat, has been in Congress for more than 30 years. Most of the audience reflected his concerns. There were a few Republicans, including one guy who brought up his issue with embryonic stem cell research and another who wanted to talk about immigrations. It was generally very cordial until old WWII vet who started a vocal fight with a few other attendees on the subject of troops in Iraq. The congressman is for a complete and immediate pullout.

Anyway, as we came in the auditorium, we were asked if wanted to ask a question and given numbers which the congressman called randomly. I hadn't wanted to about either the Downing Street Memo or about PBS, but others had asked these before my number came up. So when Mr. Stark called for number 19, I wasn't sure if I was going to get up and ask, but I did.

I thanked the congressman for being there and told that I just moved into his district. He asked me from where, and instinctively, I said from Samoa where I was in the Peace Corps. Everyone in the audience started clapping which was seriously embarrassing. I could have said Walnut Creek or Vail, CO, and each would have been true but would have suggested something about me that's inaccurate, but I digress.

In answering the questioner about PBS the congressman made some qualitative remarks equating PBS with Rush Limbaugh. He said something like on the one hand PBS does its thing and on the other hand Rush Limbaugh does his thing. I made a comment about how this was a spurious analogy. Then I turned to the Republican who questioned the morality of the embryonic stem cell research and I said it was great that he was here, it took some serious fortitude to come, but I believe he represented a widely misunderstood view that embryos are humans with arms and legs when in fact they are nothing more than microscopic undifferentiated cells that are going to be destroyed anyway. His response: "That's your opinion."

I was stunned by this response. I guess I shouldn't have been, but I was. Right now we have a huge problem in this country that is caused by blurring the lines between fact and opinion. When I can state a fact, i.e. that embryos are cells and don't have limbs and am told that's my opinion, what are the "facts" that this guy is basing his opinion on? Clearly his "facts" are wrong and therefore any opinion based on those facts is going to be deeply flawed. But I suppose religious dogma trumps reality every time.

So I asked Mr. Stark my question which was about a James Sensenbrenner (R-WI) bill HR 1528, entitled Defending America's Most Vulnerable: Safe Access to Drug Treatment and Child Protection Act of 2005. Keeping drugs away from children is a good thing, but there's a section of the bill that requires people who have knowledge of any drug related activity to report that information to the police within 24 hours. The penalty for not doing so would be a felony punishable by a minimum of two years. I asked what was being done about this. Curiously the congressman hadn't read the bill, hadn't even heard of it. He asked me to email him about it and I have.

My question was towards the end, and the meeting ended, people started dispersing. As I was leaving people started to come up to me either to engage me in their political activism, which I have no interest in, or to talk about the Peace Corps, which is always interesting.

A couple of things were notable about this experience. The first is that there was no security of any kind. As I came in the door, all I was asked was if I wanted to ask a question. They didn't ask for ID. They didn't ask for party affiliation. They didn't ask whom I voted for. They didn't even check my bags. This is how a democracy is supposed to function and the fact that it even comes to my attention is a problem. The second is that Pete Stark took unsolicited, unscreened questions from everyone and anyone. People asked about all sorts of things from issues I mentioned about to base closures, the Patriot Act, Social Security, and everything in between. It was very refreshing.

The whole meeting was in stark contradistinction from the "town hall meetings" that George Bush is holding around the country to drum up support for his Social Security reform plans where the crowds are hand picked and the questions are preselected while Americans taxpayers pick up the whole tab for the entire charade.

I doubt I'll become a regular at these events, as some of those people clearly were, but it was enlightening and it feels good to be part of the political process.

Posted by andrew at June 6, 2005 10:48 AM


Comments

J Says:

That's really fantastic Andrew. It's great that you took the time to find out who represented you.
I have no idea who represents me. Oh, yup, I've just found out, his name is....... Merlin Baboujon. Huh! No party afilliation. He seems to be a potent sketchy character of a beastly and ungreatful nature. I like him already.

June 6, 2005 12:23 PM
Andrew Writes:

Based on his less than pleasant disposition, I'm guessing Mer is a Republicat.

June 6, 2005 01:11 PM
JenBen Says:

I just got back from your neck of the woods. We stayed in Petaluma over the weekend. Was a nice change of pace but how do you stand the traffic there? Ugh!

June 6, 2005 02:23 PM
Andrew Writes:

The traffic is easy to deal with. I just know where not to go when. Simple as that.

June 6, 2005 02:34 PM
JenBen Says:

Well, don't go to Petaluma from Oakland at 3pm on Thursdays.

June 6, 2005 09:15 PM
Andrew Writes:

Wouldn't dream of it.

June 6, 2005 09:18 PM
kalapu Says:

WEll, RPCV is a bit more 'american idle' than ski bum photog.

You know, those feelings, that pc brain boost, need not end just because you have come back to the wasteland. Volunteer opportunities exist everywhere you step; particularly in this day and age when it is so uncool to spend any money or effort on those who have failed in right thought and become unfortunate.

As one who has watched your transition back into desert life I would venture the opinion that a large dose of volunteer work would do you a world of good.

If nothing else it will give you something else to pin your identity to than a fast aging year in the middle of the pacific.

Who knows...you become active in an appropriate kind of helping and you might stop whinning about the Inevitable deterioration of the society around you.

Just remember...good volunteer work is like the corps, it takes some training, and starts off slow, but after a while it is quite a personal benefit.

June 15, 2005 11:22 AM
Andrew Writes:

You "watched" me transition? Fascinating.

June 15, 2005 11:29 AM
kalapu Says:

WeLL i HAVE OCCASIONALLY READ ABOUT HOW YOU HAVE GONE FROM BEING A WORTHLESS PCV TO JUST BEING WORTHLESS. THE TRAIT IS AT TIMES ADMIRABLE IN A VOLUNTEER. iT'S A SHAME YOU FAILED TO MASTER THE ART WHILE IN SAMOA. PERHAPS IT EXPLAINS YOUR PREOCCUPATION WITH THE STATE OF BEING AFTER YOUR EARLY DEPARTURE FROM THE LAND OF THE SACRED CHICKEN.

sINCE BY YOUR OWN ADMISSION YOU DON'T HAVE ANY OTHER IDENTITY BUT RPCV, i THOUGHT YOU MIGHT WANT TO CONTEMPLATE CONTINUING THE KARMIC TRIP AND COMPLETING THE CIRCLE BY PUTTING IN THAT LOST YEAR VOLUNTEERING IN THE WORLD THAT NOW SURROUNDS YOU.

June 16, 2005 04:23 PM




Remember me?

(You may use HTML tags for style)

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.americanidle.org/MT/mt-tb.cgi/1214

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference:
'A Real Town Hall Meeting'.