06 April 2005Books
Whatever a Man Never Has, He Never Misses

I just finished reading One Man's Wilderness, Sam Keith's presentation of Dick Proenneke's Alaskan Journals. I caught the PBS special, Alone in the Wilderness back in March, and quickly became enamored with the Proenneke world. I picked up the book at the library. With a few notable exceptions, the book pretty much reads like a transcript of the documentary. Proenneke's words, like his lifestyle, are very simple. You won't find any metaphor or simile or clever turns of phrase. But you will find straightforward, honest writing from a modern mountain of Emersonian self-reliance. It's very impressive. In fact, the whole book is a commentary on the evils of materialism. Here's how Proenneke sums it up in his Reflections section.

Needs? I guess that is what bothers so many folks. They keep expanding their needs until they are dependent on too many things and too many other people. I don't understand economics, and I suppose the country would be in a real mess if people suddenly cut out a lot of things they don't need. I wonder how many things in the average American home could be eliminated if the question were asked, "Must I really have this?" I guess most of the extras are chalked up to comfort or saving time.

This is the exact same sentiment embodied by Tyler Durden in Fight Club when he tells Jack (just before they pummel each other for the first time), "The things you own, they end up owning you."

I don't know about you, but I feel trapped by the things I own. My books. My music. My furniture. And now my cats (although, truth be told, they really do own me). I had to pay for a storage place when I was in the Peace Corps. And now my things don't quite overwhelm me, but they keep me pinned down, unable to make the decisions I want, to do the things I want, when I want.

It's a choice I've made to sacrifice the some of the mobility of my past on the altar of stability. We'll see how long it lasts, probably as long as I'm responsible for the Samoan Fighting Kittens, which could be a long, long time.

Posted by andrew at April 6, 2005 02:00 PM


Comments

Phil Says:

Andrew-

Interesting review. The juxtaposition of One Man's Wilderness and Fight Club is certainly an unorthodox marriage, but you're right about their shared message on materialism. Visiting One Man's Wilderness again:

"To see game you must move a little and look a lot. What first appears to be a branch turns into that big caribou bull up there on the benches- I wonder what he thinks about? Is his brain just a blank as he lies there blinking in the sun and chewing his cud? I wonder if he feels as I do, that this small part of the world is enough to think about?"

For anyone seeking some perspective on the world and the "stuff" that now fills it, Dick Proenneke's journals (compiled by Sam Keith) in One Man's Wilderness is an excellent read.

April 18, 2005 09:45 AM
Andrew Writes:

There are so many quotes you can pull from the text. Proenneke is a model of efficient simplicity. I think that's why he seems to have struck a chord with so many people who's lives are inexplicably complicated.

April 18, 2005 12:21 PM
BRIAN Says:

Anyone who has seen the documentary 'Alone in the Wilderness' about Dick Proenneke's life in Alaska can quickly see that he has a ton of possessions he couldn't live without. A canoe, tools, pots and pans, storage containers, rolls of polyethalene, guns and ammunition, fishing gear, etc. There's no difference between his affection for the vice-grips he uses to 'create' his storage tins and my girlfriends love for her IPOD.

June 8, 2005 11:03 AM
Andrew Writes:

No difference? Are you sure? Why doesn't your girlfriend go out to the Alaska wilderness and see how long she'll enjoy her iPod without electricity?

I think you've missed the point.

June 8, 2005 11:07 AM




Remember me?

(You may use HTML tags for style)

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.americanidle.org/MT/mt-tb.cgi/1114

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference:
'Whatever a Man Never Has, He Never Misses'.